Background to the proposal
In recent weeks the Mayor of Greater Manchester, Andy Burnham, has signalled a willingness to explore reductions in National Insurance contributions for companies that hire workers under the age of 25. The idea is presented as a targeted response to the persistent youth unemployment problem that has been highlighted in several government reports.
What the Milburn report recommends
The Milburn report, commissioned by the Department for Work and Pensions, outlines a series of measures aimed at lowering the cost of hiring young people. Among the recommendations is a specific reduction in the employer National Insurance rate for staff aged 16 to 24. Burnham has said he will consider these suggestions "very carefully" and is open to further input from business groups.
Key points from the report
- Reduce employer NICs for under‑25s by up to 2 percentage points.
- Introduce a wage subsidy for apprentices earning below the living wage.
- Create a national database of youth vacancies to improve matching.
Potential impact on NEETs
The term NEET – not in education, employment or training – describes a segment of young people who are most at risk of long‑term exclusion from the labour market. According to the Office for National Statistics, the UK recorded around 1.1 million NEETs in the latest quarter, a figure that has risen since the pandemic.
Lowering employer NICs could make hiring younger workers more attractive, potentially reducing the NEET count. The expected benefits include:
- Increased entry‑level positions in retail, hospitality and care sectors.
- Greater on‑the‑job training opportunities that lead to skill development.
- Improved earnings prospects for young people entering the workforce for the first time.
Fiscal implications for businesses
From a business perspective, the proposal promises a direct reduction in payroll costs. For a company employing ten workers aged 22, a 2 percent cut in NICs could save roughly £1,200 per year, based on average salaries. Smaller firms, which often operate on thin margins, may find the incentive particularly valuable.
However, critics argue that the savings might be offset by other fiscal pressures, such as rising energy costs and inflation‑linked wage demands. The Institute for Fiscal Studies notes that any reduction in NIC revenue would need to be compensated by either higher taxes elsewhere or a reallocation of public spending.
Considerations for employers
Employers should evaluate the following before relying on the incentive:
- Eligibility criteria – the reduction applies only to employees under 25 who are on a permanent contract.
- Administrative changes – payroll systems will need to be updated to apply the lower rate.
- Long‑term commitment – the policy may be time‑limited, so firms should assess sustainability.
Political reactions
Burnham’s remarks have drawn mixed responses across the political spectrum. The opposition Labour Party, now led by Keir Starmer, has praised the focus on youth jobs but warned that cuts to NICs could erode the social safety net. Former Chancellor Rachel Reeves, who served under the previous Labour government, suggested that a broader overhaul of the welfare system would be needed to address the root causes of youth unemployment.
Business groups such as the Confederation of British Industry have welcomed the idea, describing it as a "pragmatic step" to stimulate hiring. Conversely, trade unions have expressed concern that lower contributions could lead to reduced funding for public services, including those that support young people’s training.
Next steps and timeline
The proposal is not yet law. Burnham indicated that any changes would be subject to detailed analysis and consultation with stakeholders. The expected timeline includes:
- Commissioning an impact assessment – due by the end of the next quarter.
- Public consultation – a six‑week period for businesses, NGOs and individuals to comment.
- Parliamentary debate – a scheduled session in early 2025.
If approved, the reduced NIC rate could take effect from the start of the 2025‑26 fiscal year. In the meantime, the mayor’s office plans to launch a pilot programme in Manchester, offering a temporary NIC discount to a handful of local firms willing to employ young apprentices.
Broader context of the UK youth job crisis
Beyond the NIC proposal, the UK faces structural challenges that affect young workers. Automation, a shift towards gig‑economy roles and regional disparities all play a part. A recent study by the University of Cambridge highlights that regions with higher investment in digital skills see lower youth unemployment rates.
Policy experts therefore argue that any NIC reduction should be paired with measures that improve education‑to‑employment pathways, such as expanded apprenticeship funding and stronger career guidance in schools.
In summary, Burnham’s openness to cutting National Insurance for under‑25s reflects a growing appetite for targeted fiscal tools to address the youth job gap. The success of the initiative will depend on careful design, robust evaluation and coordination with wider strategies aimed at upskilling the next generation of workers.
Comments
No comments yet. Be first.
Please log in to comment.