Nexstar Faces Ninth Circuit Scrutiny Over Tegna Merger Strategy

4 min read
Nexstar Faces Ninth Circuit Scrutiny Over Tegna Merger Strategy

Background of the Nexstar‑Tegna Deal

Nexstar Media Group announced a $6.2 billion offer to acquire Tegna Inc. in early 2023. The transaction would combine two of the largest owners of local television stations in the United States, creating a broadcast powerhouse with more than 200 stations nationwide. Proponents argued that the merger would generate operational efficiencies, boost digital advertising capabilities, and strengthen the financial position of both companies.

Legal Challenges and State Lawsuits

Within weeks of the announcement, a coalition of state attorneys general filed a lawsuit alleging that the deal would reduce competition in local news markets and give Nexstar undue influence over advertising rates. The Federal Trade Commission also opened an antitrust investigation, citing concerns that the combined entity could dominate advertising inventory in dozens of midsize markets.

In March 2024, the DOJ Antitrust Division joined the states, seeking a preliminary injunction to halt the merger pending a full review. The district court denied the request, but the decision was immediately appealed to the Ninth Circuit.

Role of the Ninth Circuit

The three‑judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals was tasked with reviewing the lower court’s order and assessing whether Nexstar’s proposed modifications to the deal might address the antitrust concerns. The panel convened a hearing in September 2024, during which the judges pressed the Nexstar counsel for detailed explanations.

Key Questions Raised by the Judges

  • How does Nexstar intend to limit the reach of the combined station portfolio in markets where competition is already thin?
  • What specific divestitures or operational firewalls will be put in place to preserve independent editorial voices?
  • Can Nexstar demonstrate that the merger will not lead to higher advertising rates for local businesses?
  • What metrics will be used to measure compliance with any court‑ordered conditions?

Nexstar’s Response and Proposed Narrowing

During the hearing, Nexstar’s attorney outlined a “narrowed” version of the transaction that would involve selling a subset of stations in overlapping markets to third‑party buyers. The company also offered to establish a “firewall” agreement that would keep newsrooms independent and prevent the sharing of advertising sales data across the merged entity.

In a filing submitted to the court, Nexstar referenced a precedent set by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in the 2021 Sinclair‑Tribune case, where the court required divestitures to preserve competition. Nexstar argued that its proposed divestitures would satisfy the same standard.

Critics, however, pointed out that the list of stations earmarked for sale was limited and that many of the remaining stations would still dominate local advertising markets. A media analyst quoted in a Reuters report on the lawsuit warned that the “narrowed” approach might not be enough to allay antitrust worries.

Potential Outcomes for the Broadcast Landscape

The Ninth Circuit’s decision will have far‑reaching implications for the future of broadcast consolidation in the United States. Three possible outcomes have emerged from legal analysts:

  1. Full Approval with Conditions – The court could allow the merger to proceed if Nexstar completes the proposed divestitures and adheres to strict editorial firewalls.
  2. Partial Block – The judges might block the transaction in specific markets where competition is weakest, forcing Nexstar to restructure the deal further.
  3. Complete Halt – The panel could uphold the original injunction, effectively ending the merger and preserving the status quo.

Impact on Local News Markets

Local newsrooms are already under pressure from declining ad revenue and audience fragmentation. A merger of this scale could either provide the financial resources needed to invest in digital platforms, or it could concentrate ownership to the point where editorial diversity suffers. Community groups have voiced concerns that fewer owners could lead to homogenized news coverage and reduced investigative reporting.

Regulatory Implications

The case also serves as a barometer for how federal and state regulators will handle future media consolidations. A ruling that favors Nexstar’s narrowed proposal may signal a more flexible approach, encouraging other broadcasters to pursue similar strategies. Conversely, a stringent decision could embolden regulators to scrutinize large‑scale deals more aggressively.

Regardless of the outcome, the hearing highlighted the growing tension between the business goals of media conglomerates and the public interest in maintaining a competitive, diverse news ecosystem.

Stakeholders across the industry will be watching the Ninth Circuit’s ruling closely, as it will shape the strategic calculations of broadcasters, advertisers, and policymakers for years to come.

Comments

No comments yet. Be first.

More from this author