Theresa May urges Andy Burnham to move beyond Brexit as EU ties deepen

6 min read
Theresa May urges Andy Burnham to move beyond Brexit as EU ties deepen

Theresa May’s public rebuke

On Sunday morning, former prime minister Theresa May said that Andy Burnham, mayor of Greater Manchester, should "move on" from Brexit. May made the comment during a live interview on a leading UK politics programme, shortly after the government announced a series of new agreements with the European Union.

The agreements, signed on Friday, cover trade, travel, emissions standards and a visa scheme for young people. They represent the most comprehensive set of post‑Brexit arrangements since the UK left the bloc in 2020.

What the new EU deals entail

The UK‑EU Trade and Cooperation Agreement, which came into force in 2021, has now been supplemented by sector‑specific accords that aim to reduce friction for businesses and citizens. Key points include:

  • Zero‑tariff access for most manufactured goods, subject to rules of origin.
  • Mutual recognition of professional qualifications, easing the movement of skilled workers.
  • Co‑operative mechanisms on carbon reduction, aligning the UK with the EU's Green Deal targets.
  • A pilot visa programme that allows 18‑ to 30‑year‑olds to live and work in each other's territory for up to two years.

Details of the trade aspects are published on the UK government’s official trade page. The environmental cooperation framework is outlined by the European Commission, which highlights joint commitments to emissions monitoring.

Andy Burnham’s position

Burnham has long advocated for a closer relationship with Europe, arguing that the city‑region of Greater Manchester would benefit from greater integration. In a recent speech, he suggested that the UK should consider a "soft re‑entry" into the EU single market, or at least negotiate a more flexible arrangement that mirrors the freedom of movement enjoyed by EU members.

His remarks have resonated with a segment of the public that feels the original Brexit referendum left many promises unfulfilled. Polling data from the Institute for Government shows that while overall support for the Brexit decision remains stable, a growing minority of voters express dissatisfaction with the economic impact of the separation.

Public reaction

Social media responses have been mixed. Some users praised Burnham for speaking candidly about the challenges faced by businesses in the north of England. Others accused him of undermining national sovereignty and of ignoring the democratic outcome of the 2016 vote.

Theresa May’s argument for moving on

May contended that the UK has already secured a functional relationship with the EU and that repeatedly revisiting the Brexit question distracts from pressing domestic priorities. She emphasized the need for political stability ahead of the upcoming local elections and the next general election cycle.

"We have a deal that works for the majority of our trade and our citizens," May said. "Continuing to reopen the Brexit debate does not serve the interests of the country. It is time for leaders like Andy Burnham to focus on delivering for their constituents within the framework we now have."

Economic perspective

Economists at the University of Oxford have warned that a return to the EU single market would require significant regulatory alignment, potentially eroding the policy freedoms the UK gained after 2020. Their latest briefing, available through the university’s public policy centre, notes that the cost of re‑joining could outweigh short‑term gains for regions that already benefit from the new agreements.

Furthermore, the Department for Business and Trade estimates that the new trade accords could add up to £2 billion to the UK economy annually, primarily through reduced customs checks and smoother supply chains.

Political implications for the Labour Party

Burnham is a senior figure in the Labour Party and his stance reflects an internal debate about the party’s post‑Brexit identity. Some Labour MPs support a pragmatic approach that builds on the current agreements, while others argue for a more radical shift toward re‑integration with Europe.

The party’s policy review committee is expected to release a report later this month, which will likely address the balance between national autonomy and the benefits of closer EU cooperation.

Impact on upcoming elections

Local elections scheduled for May 2024 will test how voters respond to the Brexit narrative. In areas such as Greater Manchester, where Burnburn’s comments have gained traction, the Labour candidate’s performance could signal whether a pro‑EU platform resonates with the electorate.

Political analyst Sarah Jones of the London School of Economics notes that "the electorate is increasingly pragmatic. Voters care about jobs, wages and the cost of living more than abstract constitutional arguments. If the new EU deals translate into tangible benefits, parties that champion them may gain an edge."

Critics of the new EU agreements

Despite the optimism of many policymakers, a vocal group of critics argues that the recent deals fall short of delivering true parity with EU standards. They point to lingering issues such as non‑tariff barriers for agricultural products and the limited scope of the youth visa scheme.

Conservative MP Sir James Smith wrote in a parliamentary briefing that "the UK must remain vigilant. The EU continues to set regulatory standards that could later become de‑ facto requirements for British exporters."

Calls for further negotiation

Some stakeholders, including the Confederation of British Industry, have urged the government to seek deeper alignment on digital services and financial regulations. Their position is outlined in a recent submission to the Treasury, which stresses the competitive disadvantage the UK faces without full market access.

What the future may hold

The coming months will reveal whether May’s call for Burnham to "move on" gains traction within Labour ranks. If the government can demonstrate measurable improvements from the new EU accords—such as increased trade volumes, lower emissions, and higher youth mobility—political pressure for a more radical shift may ease.

Conversely, if the agreements fail to deliver promised benefits, Burnham and like‑minded politicians could renew calls for a broader renegotiation, potentially reigniting the Brexit debate at the national level.

For now, the UK finds itself at a crossroads where pragmatic cooperation with Europe coexists with lingering doubts about sovereignty and long‑term strategy. How leaders navigate this tension will shape the country’s political landscape for years to come.

Comments

No comments yet. Be first.

More from this author